Buy the 4th gen, keep a working 3rd gen, or skip Nest

Google Nest Learning Thermostat circular display on a round wall plate

If you already own a 3rd-gen unit that still appears in the Nest or Google Home app, this google nest learning thermostat long term review says keep it. Buy the 4th gen only if you live in Google Home, want a temperature sensor in the box, and accept that setup still goes through Google. Skip Nest as a first purchase if Apple HomeKit or local Home Assistant is the control plane you actually use.

On November 20, 2026 the Google Store US listing showed the Nest Learning Thermostat (4th gen) at $219.99 on a $279.99 list, through December 2, 2026 while supplies last. The box includes one Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd gen). Extra sensors list at $39.99 each, up to six per thermostat.

Figures, compatibility notes, and app limits below come from Google’s current store and Help pages, independent coverage of Nest’s 2015 bill studies, 9to5Google’s Matter write-up, and ecobee’s own Premium spec page. No household runtime log sits behind this article.

Situation2026 move
Working 3rd gen (2015) still in Nest or HomeKeep it. Google’s community post on the 1st/2nd-gen sunset says 3rd gen, Thermostat E, the 2020 Nest Thermostat, and 4th gen keep app support and security updates.
1st gen (2011) or 2nd gen (2012 / Europe 2014)App pairing ended October 25, 2025. On-device schedules still run; remote control, notifications, and Nest Protect emergency shutoff links do not.
Buying new, Google Home household4th gen is the current Learning model: Matter for basic temperature in other apps, Google Home for learning, sensors, and setup.
Buying new, Apple Home or local Home Assistant firstLook at ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium (lists Apple HomeKit; $209.99 on a $259.99 regular price on ecobee.com when checked) or a local-first thermostat in our Home Assistant thermostat guide.

Which generation you have, and the October 2025 cutoff

The 3rd-gen Learning Thermostat shipped in 2015. Google’s product blog for that launch still cites independent studies of 10–12% heating and 15% cooling savings. That hardware is now more than a decade old, which is why “after four years” is the wrong clock for a 2026 buyer: the product line split, then the oldest units lost the app.

Google Home Help states that starting October 25, 2025, 1st- and 2nd-gen Learning Thermostats no longer connect to the Nest or Google Home apps. They are unpaired from the account. Home/Away Assist, multi-device Eco, remote temperature changes, and Nest Protect emergency shutoff no longer run through the phone. Schedules already on the device keep working, and you can still change mode and setpoints on the ring.

The same Help page is explicit that those units stop receiving software and security updates. Google’s Nest community post lists the models that were not cut: 3rd gen (including the European 3rd gen), Nest Thermostat E, Nest Thermostat (2020), and Learning Thermostat (4th gen, 2024).

If a 1st- or 2nd-gen unit is still on the wall, treat it as a local programmable thermostat with a round screen, not as a connected device. The US/Canada 4th-gen discount Google advertised for those owners was tied to codes that expired December 31, 2025.

4th gen hardware, Matter, and what stays in Google Home

Google’s spec sheet puts the 4th-gen display at 3.9 in diameter, 2.68 in LCD (600×600), with temperature, humidity, ambient light, and a Soli motion sensor. It is specified for most 24 V systems: gas, electric, oil, forced air, heat pump, and radiant, including three stages of heat and three of cooling, plus HUM, DEHUM, and VENT terminals the 3rd gen handled more awkwardly.

Retail warranty is two years; HVAC Pros can extend that to five years in the US and Canada, per Google’s Pro warranty table. ecobee lists a 3-year limited warranty on Smart Thermostat Premium.

Setup requires the Google Home app. 9to5Google’s August 2024 article notes the 4th gen will not join the legacy Nest app, so a 3rd-gen household that upgrades cannot stay on one Nest-app graph. Matter pairing can put basic temperature and mode into Apple Home or SmartThings. Learning schedules, Nest Temperature Sensor pairing, and the energy features stay in Google Home.

The cheaper Nest Thermostat (2020-style model on the same store comparison) listed at $89.99 on a $129.99 regular price the same day. It does not take Nest Temperature Sensors, uses a guided schedule instead of Smart Schedule, and Google says some heating-only, cooling-only, zoned, and heat-pump installs need a C wire or Nest Power Connector. The Learning 4th gen is the one Google positions for those extra HVAC accessories.

If you want a thermostat that does not start in Google’s cloud, read the Home Assistant roundup above and the Ecobee vs Nest vs Honeywell T9 comparison.

Energy savings: 10–12% heat studies versus the 31% store line

Google Store copy says the Learning Thermostat can help save up to 31% on heating and cooling. The footnote on that page is the method: a modeled baseline of a constant 72°F hold all year, which ASHRAE/DOE comfort ranges make look like a “typical” setpoint. Google itself says actual savings “will likely be less.”

Google’s energy-savings Help article still quotes the older measured result: on average, 10–12% on heating and 15% on cooling after install, with a $131–$145 a year figure based on the energy costs used in those studies. WIRED’s 2015 report names the three sources Nest published: Energy Trust of Oregon, Vectren in Indiana, and Nest’s MyEnergy sample across 41 states. Those were before-and-after utility bills, not a 2026 field test of the 4th gen.

Seasonal Savings, when a utility offers it, is a separate add-on. Google cites ACEEE 2018 proceedings for extra savings on the order of 3–7% cooling and 3–8% heating for households that enroll. ENERGY STAR certification for the Learning Thermostat dates to February 2017 on the same Help page; rebate eligibility still hinges on your utility, not on the certification stamp alone.

If the thermostat you are replacing already had a decent setback schedule, expect the low end of those ranges, or none. Homes replacing a dead or unused non-programmable unit are the ones the bill studies were built around. For the math on payback versus other brands, see whether smart thermostats cut the bill.

C-wire, Power Sharing, and what happens when Google is offline

Google’s 4th-gen spec still claims patented Power Sharing, so a C wire is “not required in most homes,” with a C wire or Nest Power Connector needed in “limited cases (<1%).” The 3rd gen used the same story. That is a power-budget claim at install, not a promise that an internal lithium cell will look new in year eight.

Older-home installs without a spare conductor should still run Google’s compatibility checker (g.co/nest/works) and read the C-wire notes (g.co/nest/cwire) before buying. If the furnace board cannot spare a common, budget a Power Connector or an extra conductor rather than hoping the rechargeable pack covers a long heating cycle. Wiring detail lives in our no-C-wire thermostat guide.

Google’s offline thermostat Help is clear on the split: without Wi-Fi you lose the app; you can still set temperature on the device. A Google-team answer on the 4th gen also states the saved schedule continues without Wi-Fi. During a Nest/Home service outage, Google tells people not to factory-reset or unlink; check status.nest.com and wait for devices to reconnect.

That is the long-term trade: heat and cool keep running from what is stored on the thermostat, while history, remote tweaks, Adaptive Eco, and Matter bridges sit behind Google’s servers and your LAN. If that split is unacceptable, do not buy into Nest because the 4th gen is prettier. Buy a platform whose automations are documented as local.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I buy a Nest Learning Thermostat in 2026?

Buy the 4th gen if Google Home is already your app and you want the included temperature sensor plus Matter for basic setpoints elsewhere. Keep a 3rd gen that still shows in Nest or Home. Choose another brand if HomeKit-native or local Home Assistant control is the reason you are shopping.

Did Google stop supporting older Nest Learning Thermostats?

App support for 1st gen (2011) and 2nd gen (2012, plus the 2014 European 2nd gen) ended October 25, 2025. Those units still run on-device schedules. Google says 3rd gen, Thermostat E, the 2020 Nest Thermostat, and 4th gen keep receiving updates in Nest or Home.

How much energy does a Nest Learning Thermostat save?

Google Help still cites 10–12% heating and 15% cooling averages from utility-bill studies Nest published around 2015. The store’s “up to 31%” line is versus a constant 72°F hold. Your bill move depends on the thermostat you are replacing and whether you use Eco and Seasonal Savings.

Does the Nest Learning Thermostat (4th gen) need a C-wire?

Google says Power Sharing covers most 24 V systems, with a C wire or Nest Power Connector needed in under 1% of cases. Confirm with the compatibility checker. Heat-only, cooling-only, zoned, and some heat-pump jobs are the ones Google flags on the cheaper Nest Thermostat, not as a blanket 4th-gen rule.

What happens if Wi-Fi or Google Home is down?

You can change temperature on the thermostat. Google’s offline Help, and a Google-team note on the 4th gen, say the stored schedule keeps running. App control, notifications, and cloud automations wait until Wi-Fi and Nest services return. Do not factory-reset during a published outage.